In the intricate world of diamond purchasing, understanding eye-clean diamonds is crucial for buyers seeking exceptional value without compromising on visual appeal. This comprehensive guide delves into the nuances of eye-clean diamonds, providing expert insights to help you make an informed decision.
What makes us your trusted partner
With over 40 years of expertise, Diamond Registry’s CEO and owner, Nissan Perla, is your trusted guide in the diamond-buying world. Recognized by prestigious publications like The Washington Post and Chicago Tribune, Nissan’s extensive knowledge and experience in evaluating, buying, and selling diamonds are unparalleled. Our commitment to integrity, transparency, and delivering exceptional value ensures that you make an informed decision when acquiring your timeless treasure. Choose Diamond Registry for personalized guidance, education, and a curated selection of the finest quality diamonds, backed by decades of industry expertise and dedication to your satisfaction.
What Are Eye-Clean Diamonds?
Eye-clean diamonds are those in which inclusions and blemishes are not visible to the unaided eye when viewed from the face-up position under normal lighting conditions. While these diamonds may have imperfections visible under magnification, they appear flawless to the naked eye. This classification, though not an official grading, is a practical standard used by industry experts to identify diamonds that offer an optimal balance of quality and value.
The perception of eye-cleanliness is influenced by several factors, including visual acuity, lighting conditions, and the characteristics of both the inclusions and the diamond itself. The average human eye can resolve details as small as 50 microns at a typical viewing distance, which forms the basis for what can be considered “eye-clean.” Lighting plays a crucial role, with bright, direct light often revealing more than diffused lighting. The nature of inclusions, including their size, color, and position, significantly affects their visibility. Additionally, the diamond’s shape, size, and cut quality all contribute to how well it can mask inclusions.
Finding Eye-Clean Diamonds
Finding an eye-clean diamond requires a combination of knowledge, careful evaluation, and sometimes expert assistance. Start by familiarizing yourself with the basics of diamond clarity and how different grades typically appear to the naked eye. When shopping online, utilize vendors that offer high-resolution imagery and videos. For in-person shopping, always examine diamonds under various lighting conditions.
If you need more clarification about your ability to identify eye-clean diamonds, feel free to seek expert help. Our team of gemologists is available to assist you in evaluating diamonds and can provide personalized recommendations based on your preferences and budget. This expert guidance can be invaluable in ensuring you select a truly eye-clean diamond that offers the best value.
Focus on VS2 and SI1 clarity grades
These grades often provide the best balance of value and eye cleanliness. VS2 diamonds are typically eye-clean, while many SI1 diamonds can also be eye-clean, especially in smaller sizes.
Examine inclusion location carefully
Pay close attention to where inclusions are situated within the diamond. Inclusions near the edges are often less visible and can be hidden by the setting, while those in the center are more noticeable.
Consider diamond shape
Different shapes hide inclusions to varying degrees. Round and princess cuts are particularly good at masking inclusions due to their facet patterns, while step cuts like emerald and asscher tend to reveal inclusions more readily.
Use magnified images wisely
When shopping online, take advantage of magnified images to spot potential issues. However, remember that what you see under magnification may not be visible to the naked eye. Use these images as a guide, not a definitive judgment.
Be cautious with SI2 diamonds
While SI2 diamonds can be eye-clean, especially in smaller sizes, they require more careful evaluation. If opting for an SI2, scrutinize it closely and consider expert opinions.
Prioritize cut quality
A well-cut diamond with excellent light performance can mask inclusions that would be visible in a poorly cut stone of the same clarity grade. Don’t overlook the importance of cut when searching for an eye-clean diamond.
Evaluate under different lighting
Examine the diamond under various lighting conditions. Bright, direct light often reveals more than diffused lighting. If possible, view the diamond in natural daylight as well as under store lighting.
By following these tips and taking the time to carefully evaluate each diamond, you can increase your chances of finding an eye-clean diamond that offers excellent value.
Remember, the goal is to find a diamond that appears flawless to the naked eye, regardless of its technical clarity grade.
Clarity, Shape, and Cut: The Trifecta of Eye-Cleanliness
Clarity is obviously crucial when seeking an eye-clean diamond, but shape and cut play equally important roles. The clarity scale ranges from Flawless (FL) to Included (I3), with eye-clean diamonds typically falling in the VS1 to SI1 range. However, the diamond’s shape can significantly impact how visible inclusions are. Round brilliant cuts are particularly adept at hiding inclusions due to their facet pattern, while step cuts like emerald and asscher tend to reveal inclusions more readily.
The quality of a diamond’s cut is perhaps the most critical factor in determining its eye-cleanliness. A well-cut diamond with excellent light performance can mask inclusions that would be visible in a poorly cut stone of the same clarity grade. This is why it’s often worth prioritizing cut quality over a higher clarity grade when seeking an eye-clean diamond.
2 Carat and 4 Carat Diamonds: Special Considerations
When dealing with larger diamonds, such as 2-carat or 4-carat stones, the standards for eye cleanliness become more stringent. In a 2-carat diamond, inclusions that might be invisible in a 1-carat stone can become noticeable. For these sizes, it’s often necessary to look at VS2 or even VS1 clarity grades to ensure eye cleanliness.
4-carat diamonds present an even greater challenge. At this size, even minor inclusions can become apparent to the naked eye. For 4-carat diamonds, VVS2 or VVS1 clarity may be necessary to achieve an eye-clean appearance. However, the increased size also means that cut quality becomes even more critical in masking any existing inclusions.
The GIA’s Perspective on Eye-Clean Diamonds
While the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) doesn’t officially use the term “eye-clean,” they acknowledge its significance in the diamond market. According to the GIA, diamonds in the VS2 to SI1 clarity range often fall into this category, though individual evaluation is always necessary. The GIA emphasizes that clarity should be considered alongside cut, color, and carat weight when evaluating a diamond’s overall quality and value.
Practical Evaluation of Eye-Cleanliness
When evaluating a diamond’s eye-cleanliness, use a jeweler’s loupe or microscope to identify inclusions, then view the diamond with the naked eye. Check the diamond under different types of lighting – daylight, fluorescent, and incandescent. Rotate the diamond to see how inclusions appear from different angles. Consider how the setting might hide certain inclusions. Remember that what’s visible under 10x magnification may not be noticeable to the naked eye.
Eye-Clean Diamond Frequently Asked Questions
Can SI2 diamonds be eye-clean?
Yes, SI2 diamonds can be eye-clean, particularly in smaller sizes and certain shapes. However, they require careful evaluation and are less likely to be eye-clean than higher clarity grades.
How does lighting affect the appearance of inclusions?
Bright, direct lighting tends to make inclusions more visible, while diffused lighting can help mask minor imperfections. Always examine diamonds under various lighting conditions to ensure eye cleanliness.
Are all VVS diamonds eye-clean?
While virtually all VVS diamonds are eye-clean, opting for this high clarity grade is often unnecessary and can be cost-prohibitive. Lower clarity grades can offer better value while still appearing flawless to the naked eye.
How does fluorescence affect eye cleanliness?
Fluorescence doesn’t directly impact eye-cleanliness, but strong fluorescence can sometimes create a hazy or milky appearance in diamonds, which might be mistaken for clarity issues.
The Bottom Line: What to Aim For
When seeking an eye-clean diamond, aim for the lowest clarity grade that still appears flawless to the naked eye. For most diamond shapes and sizes up to 2 carats, this typically means focusing on VS2 to SI1 clarity grades. Prioritize excellent cut quality, as this can significantly impact a diamond’s ability to hide minor inclusions. Always evaluate diamonds individually, using high-quality images or in-person examination, and don’t rely solely on the clarity grade. By balancing clarity with cut quality and considering the diamond’s shape and size, you can find an eye-clean diamond that offers exceptional beauty and value.
